| 2009-10 NESCAC Champions | ||
| Sport | Champion | Runner-Up |
| Baseball | Tufts | Bowdoin |
| Men's Basketball | Williams |
Middlebury |
| Women's Basketball | Amherst |
Colby |
| Men's Cross Country | Williams | Amherst |
| Women's Cross Country | Middlebury |
Williams |
| Field Hockey | Tufts |
Trinity |
| Football | Amherst |
Trinity & Williams |
| Golf | Trinity |
Middlebury |
| Men's Ice Hockey | Middlebury |
Bowdoin |
| Women's Ice Hockey | Amherst |
Trinity |
| Men's Lacrosse | Tufts |
Middlebury |
| Women's Lacrosse | Williams |
Colby |
| Men's Rowing | Williams |
Trinity |
| Women's Rowing | Williams |
Trinity |
| Men's Soccer | Williams |
Middlebury |
| Women's Soccer | Williams |
Middlebury |
| Softball | Wesleyan |
Bowdoin |
| Men's Squash | Trinity |
Williams |
| Women's Squash | Trinity |
Williams |
| Men's Swimming & Diving | Williams |
Tufts |
| Women's Swimming & Diving | Williams |
Amherst |
| Men's Tennis | Middlebury |
Williams |
| Women's Tennis | Amherst |
Williams |
| Men's Track & Field | Williams |
Tufts |
| Women's Track & Field | Williams |
Tufts |
| Volleyball | Williams |
Tufts |
| Total Championships -
Williams 12, Amherst 4, Middlebury 3, Trinity 3, Tufts 3, Wesleyan
1 |
||
